I'm not sure you've cooked this correctly! Are you sure you used butter? Sometimes it's hard to believe it's not butter. Might as well place it in your world to remind you that perfection takes time!
Failed Butter Lamb price in Growtopia: sells for about 3 DL (median of 3 offers from community Discords, past 30 days). Live price chart and the latest buy and sell offers.
Recently sold at: CDTOT, ILACU